Drummer instruction tapes/cd?

[flattop32355]

There seems to be plenty of recordings of bugle calls: Is anyone aware of a tape or cd that teaches the same for beginning drummers?

Thanks in advance for any info.

Bernard Biederman
30th OVI
Co. B

[Alamo Guard]

I know in our battalion the new fresh fish drumers are just taught by the old hands. They get together at drill before hand and just go through the ropes, teaching and learning. I might suggest though you learn "firing by the drum". Easier to hear several drummers beating out that call on the battlefield than some poor horse throated major trying to scream above the din of the battlefield.

Dusty Lind

[markj]

Hi,

I have never seen the type of CD or tape you desire although I'm rather stumped as to why they're apparently not available--this seems like a significant oversight. You might want to check with the "Civil War Fife and Drum" site and ask a question there, if you haven't done so already:

http://www.geocities.com/cwfifedrum/

In my case, I lucked out. My brother is a very talented drummer, and former member of a nationally-known RevWar fife and drum corps, so I was able to have him tape all the drum/skirmish calls out of "Casey's" for my listening pleasure. The tape quality isn't that great but, if you'd like it, let me know and I'll dub you a copy as time permits.

"Firing by drum" sounds and looks impressive but, historically speaking, I don't think it's particularly accurate. Per such works as "Casey," drummers were only used to deliver skirmish commands when buglers were not otherwise available. As a rule, drummers were pressed into service during engagements to assist the wounded, which only seems logical. I can't immediately remember ever seeing an account indicating that drummers were used to provide firing commands during the war. Perhaps a search of the "Official Records" might provide more evidence for this practice.

Regards,

Mark Jaeger

[flattop32355]

Originally Posted by markj

You might want to check with the "Civil War Fife and Drum" site and ask a question there, if you haven't done so already:

http://www.geocities.com/cwfifedrum/

In my case, I lucked out. My brother is a very talented drummer, and former member of a nationally-known RevWar fife and drum corps, so I was able to have him tape all the drum/skirmish calls out of "Casey's" for my listening pleasure. The tape quality isn't that great but, if you'd like it, let me know and I'll dub you a copy as time permits.

Mark Jaeger

Had already looked at the site; no success.
I would greatly appreciate a copy of the tape. It can be sent to:
Bernard Biederman
298 Highland Ave.
Worthington, OH 43085

Your humble servant,

Bernard Biederman
30th OVI
Co. B

[RJSamp]

To learn how to drum you learn the rudiments. Those are available in any elementary percussion instruction manual...see your local music store. Once you know the difference between a drag, flam, paradiddle, and 7 stroke roll you can begin to think about the actual duty and battlefield beats.

Bruce and Emmet is Mandatory for learning the duty beats and the role of a drummer during the American Civil War. Casey's has the battlefield beats (never used nor recognized in ACW reenacting). Most drummers in ACW reenacting learn the same way the original drummers did.....from the Principal Musician or Principal Drummer. The Late Don Hubbard's Fort Delaware Field Music School is highly recommended to be attended.

I have a tape of all beats in Casey's $6 delivered.

RJ Samp
rjsamp@ameritech.net

[markj]

Hi Bernard,

I would respectfully suggest you go with R. J. Samp's product since the quality of my tape is strictly "amateur hour" and was never specifically intended for distribution outside of my unit. I have one of the CD's R. J. made for the 1821 Hanoverian bugle calls (reportedly used by some German units in the 11th Army Corps) and it's quite good.

The question as to whether drummers were actually used to deliver skirmish/firing commands during engagements remains intriguing and vexing to me. However such occurrences apparently rarely, if ever, happened so I would opine it's best to save "firing by drum" strictly for living history demonstrations rather than "battles."

Indeed, I would submit that, given the situations actual skirmishers often found themselves in, the position of drummer could be as unwieldly as it was suicidal. Interestingly, there is plenty of evidence showing that the PRUSSIAN army did use drummers to beat out firing commands during the Prusso-Danish and Austro-Prussian Wars of 1864 and 1866. But, of course, this doesn't apply to the ACW.

Regards,

Mark Jaeger

[FederalDrummerBoy]

I agree with RJ Samp. Learning the drum is much different than learning the bugle. You can not just sit down and listen to a recording and expect to be an expert by the next day. You must first purchase a manual, such as Bruce and Emmet, which is very well known, or any other one. Then you need to either teach yourself every rudiment or find a rudimental drum teacher(recommended). Once you have learned the rudiments you can then begin to read the duty calls and read the music.

Bruce and Emmet can be purchased by almost any sutler or online at Beafifer.com. The reason why most drummers in the hobby today are not profficient on their instruments is because they have not taken the time to learn the basics. They hear others with experience play and then they try to copy what they hear.

Alex Kuhn
Camp Chase Fifes and Drums

[pfeiffer3964]

Originally Posted by FederalDrummerBoy

You must... find a rudimental drum teacher(recommended). Once you have learned the rudiments you can then begin to read the duty calls and read the music.

I'll second that motion! A beginning drummer will progress much quicker with the one-on-one attention given in private lessons. Thus, I would suggest that you check the local phone book for a private teacher. After teaching the basics, a good teacher will tailor the lessons to the student’s desires and assist him with the duty calls, &c. My son's teacher, who was my teacher for 13 years, charges $12.00 per ½ hour lesson. It is definitely worth it.

I think in one of the other threads you mentioned that your son is the drummer in your household. In my area, kids are able to begin taking music lessons at school beginning in 4th or 5th grade. Depending on your son’s age, this may also be an option.

But, again, private lessons are definitely worth the time and expense. Of course… he’ll still need to practice!

--Jim

[flattop32355]

Originally Posted by pfeiffer3964

I think in one of the other threads you mentioned that your son is the drummer in your household. In my area, kids are able to begin taking music lessons at school beginning in 4th or 5th grade. Depending on your son’s age, this may also be an option.--Jim

Yes, my son is the beginner drummer. He started taking percussion this year in 6th grade band so he can become our company's drummer, but so far, they have only been working on the bells, not the drum pad. I would like to get him functional before the spring so he is an asset to the company (He really wants to be something useful, not just running around), even if it's only knowing how to play the basic calls properly. Due to his mild disabilities, he seems to learn best by repetition; the trick is to get him repeating the CORRECT way to play the calls rather than an incorrect way that gets imprinted on him and has to be unlearned. If we hit it right the first time, it will make his experience much easier and better for the unit.

Regards,

Bernard Biederman
30th OVI
Co. B

[Alamo Guard]

The March 1999 Camp Chase Gazette has a nice little article called "Essential Calls For the Infantry Camp". They have a few drum "rolls" for various commands.
As far as documentation of drumers being on the firing line, I remember the accounts of Johnny Clem at Shiloh. He said he was on the lines when a piece of shell destroyed his drum, he grabbed the a musket and the rest is history.